Nyere returned to football in 2011 after a two-year hiatus following college. He signed with the Philadelphia Soul of the Arena Football League, where he started 14 games as a rookie. He spent 2012 with the Cleveland Gladiators where he racked up three receptions for 30 yards and a touchdown in 12 starts. In 2013, Nyere dressed in 14 games for the New Orleans VooDoo, recording two receptions for 21 yards and a touchdown. Nyere was signed as a free agent with the BC Lions in October 2013 during the club's practice roster expansion period.