Crapigna became Canadian Interuniversity Sport’s all-time leader in field goals on Oct. 18, 2014, when he kicked four field goals in a game against Wilfrid Laurier to break the previous record of 82. He also set a single-season record for Ontario University Athletics. Crapigna converted on 24 of 27 field goals for the season — an 88.9-per cent success rate — and added 25 extra points for a total of 97 points as he was named a first-team OUA and CIS all-star. For his career, Crapigna kicked 84 field goals, six singles and 140 extra points for a total of 398 points in his five-year career with the Marauders. He also amassed 9,489 punting yards. He made 16 field goals in 19 attempts for an 84.0 field goal percentage in 2013. In 2012, Crapigna kicked a perfect season, splitting the uprights 18 out of 18 times on field goals adding 30 out of 30 extra points. In 2011, Crapigna scored 18 field goals on 21 attempts for an 86.0-per cent success rate. 2010 saw Crapigna kicking eight field goals in six games.